EFL Movie Study Guide for:
Titanic
from www.krigline.com www.krigline.com.cn
Several movies have been made about the tragedy. You
should be able to use this study guide with any of them. Here are three:
A Night to Remember (Titanic)—This
1950s film version of the April 14, 1912, calamity has been called one of
Britain’s best cinema productions. Based on a best-selling book by Walter
Lord. He contacted 64 survivors and poured 20 years of extensive research
into his authoritative account of one of history’s greatest disasters. The
film combines several characters to save time, but most of the events
portrayed actually happened (unlike the fictional romances in the
following two titles). It’s
also
only two hours long, so you’ll have time to discuss the film after
watching it. (1958, drama/history. Black & white. About 2 hours)
Titanic—In April of 1912 the unsinkable
Titanic sunk. This blockbuster of a fictional romance during the journey
presents a picture of life in an era when blinding arrogance made people
forget that humans are fallible. (1997; romance/drama/history;11 Oscars,
including Best Picture; about 4 hours LONG!) #1 box office success in
history (as of April 2006). (PG-13 for disaster related peril and
violence, nudity, sensuality, brief language)
Titanic—Made for TV in 1995 by Hallmark. It's
almost as long as the 1997 blockbuster, and also features fictional romances
(two, in fact), but it shows a few historical things the Oscar-winner
missed. (1995; romance/drama/history; about 3.5 hours LONG!). (PG-13 for disaster related peril and
violence, rape, adultery, sensuality, brief language)
|
Some of the “real” main characters (and other proper nouns):
Note: Different films present different aspects of
the tragedy, and may not show all of these
Titanic officers & crew: First Officer Murdoch (died), Second Officer
Lightoller (survived on an overturned collapsible); Fifth Officer Lowe
(survived in one of the boats which returned for passengers, but they only
saved six from the freezing water), Harold Bride and Jack Phillips
(wireless operators; Bride survived)
Cape Race: a place in Canada to which ships sent messages by
telegraph/Marconi; the messages (called “Cape Race traffic” could be heard
by other ships; the operator at Cape Race then sent the messages on to the
US or Canada)
Captain Smith: captain of the Titanic (died; how he died is uncertain)
Captain Lord: captain of the Californian, a freighter about 10 miles from
the Titanic at the time of the accident (it had stopped because of the
ice, and had turned off its telegraph for the night)
Captian Rostron: captain of the Carpathia, a passenger ship that steamed 4
hours north in response to Titanic's distress signals
Mr. & Mrs. Hudson Allison, Lorraine (age 2) and Trevor (baby)
Alice Cleaver: nanny who took care of the Allison children (I believe she
saved Trevor, but the rest of the Allison family died)
Thomas Andrews: the ship's designer/builder (worked for Harland & Wolff
Shipyard) (died)
John Jacob & Madeline Astor: JJ was one of the wealthiest men in the
world; age 47, he had just married Madeline (age 19). In one movie, the
Astor’s maid is called Marge Miller. (John died)
Molly Brown: a wealthy American who was raised poor and got rich because
of a gold mine; she used a lot of her money to travel and enjoyed donating
money and things to museums, schools, etc.
Sir Cosmo and Lady Duff-Gordon (though they signed onto the ship as Mr &
Mrs Morgan, perhaps to hide from fans): She designed expensive dresses;
he’d been an Olympic fencer (UK 1908); together they were on lifeboat 1,
with only 12 people. Lady Duff is remembered for suggesting that they
would be swamped if they rowed back for survivors, even though their boat
had 20 empty seats. (both survived)
Benjamin Guggenheim: a very wealthy man who was traveling with Ms. Aubart
(who wasn't his wife) (he died)
Mr. Bruce Ismay, Managing Director of the White Star Line (owner of the
Titanic) and son of the founder of the White Star Line (survived)
Charles Joughin: the Chief Baker; he had been drinking whiskey that night
(against the company's rules), and simply stepped off the back when the
ship sank (like Jack and Rose in one movie, but there was no suction). He
was in the water an amazing two hours (without being hurt) before being
pulled into a lifeboat. (Most of the people in the water died within 20
minutes.)
The Lusitania: in 1907, another ship company launched this fast and
luxurious ship; Titanic and her two sister ships were created to compete
with the Lusitania. (It was sunk by a German submarine in 1915, during
World War I.)
Isidor & Ida Straus: co-owner of Macy's, a famous New York department
store (Mrs Straus refused to leave her husband; both were lost)
Fictional characters in some of the Titanic movies:
Rose: wealthy young woman who feels that being “upper class” is a lot like
being confined (she thinks life should be more fun and carefree)
Jack: a young American artist who wins a ticket to the Titanic by
gambling; later he says Rose’s life (when she tried to kill herself) and
then they fall in love
Caledon Hockley: the rich man who wanted Rose to marry him (and later
tries to kill Jack); in truth, Mr. Ismay stayed in the expensive room
shown as Hockley’s in the movie.
Jamie Peirse (later called “Mr Dickie”): thief who boarded with a ticket
stolen from a drunk named Merrian Dickie; Jamie is torn between his old
desires as a thief and his new love for an immigrant named Osa
Mrs. Isabella Paradine; wealthy American who had visited England because
of an aunt's death (at first she wears black as a symbol of mourning); she
is in love with a pre-marriage boyfriend named Wynn Park.
Wynn Park: Mrs. Paradine’s former boyfriend; he is on the Titanic to try
to win her back.
Miss Osa Ludvigsen: from Denmark, immigrating to America with a group of
Christians in the 3rd class part of the ship; they are probably moving to
America for religious freedom (Osa is referred to as a “convert”).
Black-Billy & Clarinda Jack: family with 4 children immigrating to America
(Osa a part of their "flock" of Christian believers)
Mr. & Mrs. Foley: wealthy and snobbish 1st class passengers, traveling
with their granddaughter Lulu
Sir Richard and Lady: In A Night to Remember, this couple
represents first class British passengers, but in particular Sir Cosmo and
Lady Duff-Gordon (see above)
Robert Lucas, his wife and children: representing families
who watched a loved husband/father stay behind
Mr and Mrs Clarke: representing the many newlywed couples
on the ship
A few terms
(vocabulary):
the bridge: the place where a ship’s officers control (steer) it, also
called the helm
CQD: "Come Quickly, Distress"; an older code used for an emergency (see
Morse Code)
condition: “in your condition” or “in a delicate condition” was a way to
say that someone was going to have a baby (Mrs. Astor was pregnant--going
to have a baby)
crows nest or look out: the place high above the ship where crew members
watched for ice, land, and other ships
diamond tiara: a small jeweled crown worn in rich ladies’ hair (one movie
uses this as a symbol for wealth)
fate: a force that is believed to control your life, similar to destiny
(the purpose of your life) and luck (aspects of life you have no control
over) -- “We are together again; it must be fate”
first class: the most expensive tickets on the boat; also the most
luxurious section
a fortune: a lot of money -- “her husband made a fortune from a gold mine”
gossip: a mixture of facts and guesses about personal matters (often more
untrue than true)
iceberg: a floating “mountain” of ice that had drifted from the north
pole; remember that there is more ice under water than you can see, which
makes icebergs very dangerous
ice pack, field ice: terms related to the presence of icebergs and smaller
pieces of floating ice
immigrant: someone permanently moving from one country to another (not for
a visit, but to live there)
infamous: well known for bad reasons or because of a very bad reputation
(such as a famous criminal)
lifeboats: small boats designed to help people get off a ship in case of
emergency
Marconi or Marconi-gram: a message or the machine used to send messages by
code using radio signals (now called a telegraph)
Morse code (the verb is morsing): a series of signals (dot and dash) used
to send messages by radio or flashes of light
mourning: a time of sadness or respect for someone in your family that has
died
mug: picture of your face, often taken by the police (“Your mug has been
in the [news]papers”)
nightmare: a bad and frightening dream
pickle: literally a sour food (泡菜), but also means "an unpleasant
situation" -- “That left us in a pickle”
SOS: "Save Our Ship"; a new code (in 1914) for requesting help in an
emergency (see Morse Code)
slump: bad posture, the opposite of standing or sit up straight; “don’t
slump”
statutes: laws -- “we have complied with the statutes of the British Board
of Trade” (that is, we have the required number of lifeboats on the ship)
steerage: third class; the cheapest tickets on the boat (since many
immigrants were crossing the Atlantic at this time, this was the biggest
section of the ship)
|
Quotes to think about
(from the Hallmark movie)
Captain Smith: There is an interesting line
quoted often in the newspapers: “God himself cannot sink this ship.” She
[the Titanic] was appropriately named. The Titans dared to challenge the
gods and for their arrogance they were cast down into hell.”
Officer Lowe (after being rescued): It’s
good, ma’am, that we don’t know how things are going to end in the
beginning. Or we would never make the journeys that we were meant to take
in this life—journeys that make us who we are.
(from A Night to Remember)
Second Officer Lightoller (in a lifeboat):
There are quite a lot of ifs about it, aren’t there? If we’d been
steaming a few knots slower, or sighted that berg a few seconds earlier,
we might not have struck. If we’d carried more lifeboats, instead of just
enough to meet regulations, things would have been different again,
wouldn’t they?... I’ve been at sea since I was a boy. I’ve even been
shipwrecked before. I know what the sea can do. But this is
different…because we were so sure. Because, even though it’s happened,
it’s still unbelievable. I don’t think I’ll ever feel sure again. About
anything.
Aftermath of the tragedy:
Rescue: It took over four hours to get everyone from the lifeboats onto
the Carpathia. Men climbed up ladders, but women and children were slowly
lifted in bo’sun’s chairs (a kind of sling) or canvas bags.
The depressed and inactive crewman in charge of Molly Brown’s lifeboat was
officer Hichens, who had been at the wheel when the Titanic struck the
iceberg. When they saw the Carpathia in the early light, he insisted that
it was not a rescue ship. Against his orders, Molly eventually started
rowing toward the ship and encouraged other women to do the same (and
threatened to throw Hichens overboard if he interfered). Hichens had a
hard time finding work afterward and eventually became a harbor master in
South Africa.
On the rescue ship, first class passenger Molly Brown helped translate for
the immigrants (she spoke five languages). She later raised money for
Titanic victims, and took care of several of the wealthy widows who lost
everything (including husbands) on the Titanic. Sadly, other first class
passengers complained that no one from third class should have been saved
since so many first and second class people died.
Loraine Allison (age 2) was the only first class child lost (both parents
died too). Her nurse Alice Cleaver had taken her baby brother (Trevor)
into a lifeboat. Some people believe Alice had spent time in jail for
killing her own baby (this is uncertain). In New York, Alice lied about
her name and (perhaps) tried to keep the baby, but officials turned the
baby over to his uncle. Trevor died of food poisoning at the age of 18.
R. Norris Williams was one of 13 passengers who swam to half-sunken
collapsible A; they suffered from severe frostbite after having their
feet/legs in the frozen water for several hours. Doctors on the Carpathia
wanted to cut off his feet, but he refused. After lots of hard work Norris
continued his tennis career and twice won national championships.
Violet Jessop survived disasters on Titanic
and her two sister ships. She survived when the Olympic collided with a
navy ship (Hawke) in 1911, then became a stewardess on the Titanic (1912).
In 1916 the Britannic became a hospital ship, and she was a nurse when it
sank (probably due to a mine or torpedo in World War I). When her lifeboat
was sucked into the Britannic’s still-turning propellers, she jumped
overboard but hit her head on the lifeboat while coming up for air.
Someone grabbed her and pulled her into another boat.
Three small dogs were on Titanic’s lifeboats, including a Pekinese named
after Sun Zhong Shan (Sun Yat Sen). At least six other pet dogs drown.
Records show that 663 people survived in the 18 lifeboats that were
launched, but they were designed for 1084 people. Those saved: 290 men,
324 women, 49 children. Many men refused to get in, and the boats left
half empty. This was especially true with the first six boats, one of
which had only 12 (1:10 am) people and another had 19 (12:45 am). The last
boat left at 2:05 am (collapsible D with 40 of 47 seats full). The ship
disappeared at 2:20. On one side of the boat, the officers were strict
saying “women and children only” while the other side obeyed the captain’s
orders -- “women and children first” -- and encouraged husbands/fathers to
get in if no other women were in sight. Two boats eventually returned and
picked up nine survivors, but three of these later died. The boats had
been told to row as far away as possible so as to avoid suction, so some
were very far away when the ship went down over an hour later; oddly there
was no suction. The water was 28 degrees (-2 C).
One woman and 42 men swam to the two un-launched collapsibles. #A was
half-filled with water and had floated away; 13 later got in but two
suffered from severe frostbite after sitting in the frozen water for
hours; #B was upside down and 30 men eventually climbed onto its back,
including Second Officer Lightoller, who is credited with saving many
lives and providing invaluable testimony after the tragedy.
Records are imprecise, but around 2260 people were on the Titanic; only
706 were rescued. Over 1500 perished (died). After this disaster, the US
Coast Guard started to watch icebergs more closely. After Titanic, no
lives have been lost in the North Atlantic due to ice.
The wreckage of the Titanic was located at the bottom of the Atlantic
Ocean in 1985.
Something to think about:
One of my students once summarized the cause
of the disaster like this: “Too many people put their faith in the wrong
thing.” Another student said: “The people should have listened to the
warnings because people don’t risk sounding crazy unless the situation is
really serious.” Indeed, faith and warnings are very
important in life.
It is impossible to live without faith.
For society to function, people must exercise faith in their loved ones,
business partners, government leaders, laws, contracts/agreements, and
much more. However, it is extremely important that people wisely choose
what to put their faith in.
Because of arrogance and pride, many people
were deaf to the warnings about possible problems on the
“unsinkable” Titanic. This led to tragic choices: traveling too fast
through dangerous ice fields; carrying too few lifeboats; choosing not to
get into the first few lifeboats (because they believed the ship couldn’t
sink). Radio messages, nightmares, and shouting officers warned people of
the danger, but misplaced “faith” made people deaf to these voices;
indeed, those who warned of doom were thought to be crazy.
Today, sometimes our friends and neighbors
sound “crazy” when they try to warn us of unseen danger. “If you eat that,
you will get sick later.” “If you marry that person you will soon be
unhappy.” “If you take that job, it will hurt your career.” “If you don’t
believe what the Bible says, you will never experience God’s love—and you
will go to hell when you die.” “If you travel there now, you will be in
danger.” Remember the Titanic, and at least listen carefully to
what these people are trying to say. They risk sounding “crazy” only
because they love you and because they believe the situation is serious.
If you don’t listen, you may be risking much more than you realize.
As GK Chesterton (1874–1936; influential
British writer) once wrote: “The sign of a healthy mind is knowing when to
close it on something solid, like the truth.”
|
What were the
class/status of those saved?
Class |
M/W/Ch |
saved |
lost |
|
Total |
saved |
lost |
out of |
1st |
men |
54 |
119 |
|
men |
332 (19.6%) |
1360 |
1692 |
|
women |
141 |
10 |
|
women |
325 (76%) |
103 |
428 |
|
children |
4 |
1 |
|
children |
49 (35%) |
91 |
140 |
2nd |
men |
15 |
142 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
women |
82 |
24 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
children |
22 |
0 |
|
|
|
|
|
3rd |
men |
69 |
417 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
women |
82 |
66 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
children |
23 |
53 |
|
|
|
|
|
crew |
men |
194 |
682 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
women |
20 |
3 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
children |
0 |
0 |
|
|
|
|
|
Note: Fourteen lifeboats could hold 65 people each, two could hold 40,
the collapables (only two of the four had been properly launched)
could have held 47 each. Since no accurate record of passengers
exists, the number of those lost is only an estimate. These figures
(and some of the other facts on this study guide) came from 888.5
Amazing Answers to your Questions about the Titanic, Hugh Brewster
and Laurie Coulter, 1998, Scholastic Inc/Madison Press (Toronto)
|
Discussion Guide (intended to be used on a
different occasion, such as during an English Corner after watching the
movie)
A. Let’s begin by letting you say what you remember about
the ship and what happened. When you saw the movie, what impressed you
about this technological marvel for it’s time?
B. Several film and book versions of this
event have been very popular. As of 2006, the 1997 movie version is ranked
as the biggest box office hit in history. Tell your PARTNER why you
think the movie was so popular?
C. The workers on the ship made about $4-7
US per week. Those workers who built Titanic made 2 pounds per week
(around $10). How much do you think a 3rd class ticket cost?
How much do you think the first class cabins cost? Interestingly, Captain
Smith earned about $120 per week, while the next in command (Henry Wilde)
only earned $28 per week. (There were six officers plus the captain on the
ship, and a total of 899 crew members—685 died with the ship.) (answer: 3rd
class: $30—all your wages for over a month; 1st class $430; but
those like Rose’s and Molly Brown’s suites cost $4600
)
This brings us to a very interesting person
named Molly (or really Maggie) Brown. In the movie, Rose’s mother called
Maggie “new money”—what do you think that meant?
Maggie was born poor, and was part of a
large family. As a teenager she decided to marry a rich man, so she moved
to a town where they mined silver. At age 19 she married a man in his 30s,
and though he was not rich he worked hard and became a leader in a mining
company. Not long after that the price of silver dropped, and times got
very hard. But the Browns didn’t give up—they moved to a gold-mining area.
The Browns didn’t own the mine, but Mr. Brown worked hard and his bosses
liked him. When his company’s mine struck gold, the owners rewarded the
Browns with both money and shares in the company, and they became VERY
wealthy.
D. Some of you may be in a similar position
to Maggie at the age of around 20. Here are some things to talk about with
your partner:
1) Would marry a rich person just because
he/she is rich? How much older (than you) could your spouse be? How much
older is “too old”?
2) Assume that you have not had much
education, and you are now over 30 years old. You have two young children.
If you and your husband suddenly became rich, what would you do with the
money?
3) People from rich families (who are
raised to speak and act in “civilized” ways) often do not want to accept
the “newly rich.” If you suddenly became rich, would you try to become
accepted by the other wealthy people in your city? Why or why not? If so,
how?
4) If you had the opportunity to travel,
where would you go? How long would you stay away?
I don’t know how you answered the
discussion questions, but Maggie Brown used her money to become educated
and to educate others. She also liked to travel. As you learned from the
film, Mrs. Brown was outspoken and popular. For the most part, she was a
welcome part of Denver society, and her main contribution on the Titanic
was her ability to speak five languages—so she translated and helped the
many immigrants aboard (especially on the rescue ship). She also adopted
at least three of the destitute “wealthy” foreign women who lost fortunes
that night. Maggie was an “Irish Catholic” and throughout her life she
gave generously to many good causes, especially concerning education. She
liked to give to museums, and although she lost $27,000 worth of stuff
when Titanic sunk, she said she was most saddened by the loss of three
crates purchased ($500) in Egypt for the Denver Museum. Incidentally, on
her insurance claim for $27,000 lost on the ship, $20,000 was a single
necklace!
E. This was a time of great class
distinction, especially in Europe. This distinction was a reason for so
many Europeans trying to emigrate to America. The Titanic has 329 first
class passengers, 285 second class, 710 “steerage” (third class), and a
crew of 899. How do you think the people aboard felt? (consider each class/type
of people in turn)
(If you have an especially long class period, or if you are
using two days for this lesson, look at the Role Play
idea at the bottom of this page.)
F. When the 1st and 3rd
class people saw each other, what do you think they were thinking—did
their situations create any special feeling? DISCUSS THIS WITH A
PARTNER: Today, when a person in the countryside sees pictures of
Shanghai (or vice versa) what does he/she think and feel? How about
someone who sees pictures of London, Tokyo or Atlanta?
G. Some people think the Captain “threw
caution aside” and sped toward New York in spite of numerous ice warnings,
perhaps to set a new record. Can you think of anything people do today
“throwing caution aside”? TELL YOUR PARTNER how some of the people you
know or have read about are “throwing caution aside,” and why they do it.
If you saw the movie, try to remember what
people were doing in the last hour as the ship sank. Survivors heard many
people singing Church songs on deck—one in particular was “Nearer My
God to Thee.” (Thee is old English, and means “you” when someone is
talking to God.) In the two movies listed above, the string quartet plays
this song.
H. Now we will divide the class into three
groups, and I will give some questions for each group to discuss. When
time is up, I want a student in each group to report your group’s answers
back to the class. (see the handouts below)
After the discussion/report, if there is
more time, let students ask questions or make other comments.
I. In the time remaining, I want to open
the floor to you (that means to let you have control of what we talk
about). Do you have any questions about the Titanic or about this period
in history? Do you have any comments about the ship, the tragedy, or the
arrogant way of thinking that led to this disaster? In what ways have we
learned from the past, and in what ways are we still too arrogant? What
“disasters” might the world be heading for, and why—and what can we do to
prevent them?
(continued in the other column) |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Group 1.
You are the lucky ones. You are on a life boat, looking back as the ship
sinks. (Some of the men in your group may have to trade seats with a
lady from Group 2!) All of you have a parent, spouse, child, brother
or sister on the ship. LEADER: Ask the following questions and
try to get EVERY group member to answer.
A. Your boat is not
full. Should you turn back and look for survivors? (LEADER: AFTER
several people give answers, read this: “Historical note: some
historians say that only one or two of the 20 lifeboats really did turn back,
but not until it was almost too late. Why?”)
B. In your real life
(today), what are some of the risks involved in helping others?
C. When you see the
ship disappear, how do you feel? What do you think you will remember the
most (for the rest of your life)?
D. If you could send a
message to a loved one on the ship before it goes down, what would it be?
Group 2.
You are not as lucky as group 1. You are standing on the ship after the
last lifeboat has pulled away. LEADER: Ask the following questions and
try to get EVERY group member to answer.
A. How do you feel?
B. You have no way to
get off, but there is always the possibility that a rescue ship will come
quickly, or that the ship will not really sink. How long do you believe
that this ship is unsinkable? What will it take to make you change your
mind?
C. If your real life
(today), what does it take to make you admit that you need help from
others?
D. Once you are
convinced that the ship WILL sink, what will you do until the last moment
(you may have between 15 minutes to an hour left to live)? (LEADER:
AFTER several people give answers, read this: “Historical note:
the electricity stayed on until the very end; therefore, many workers in
the power station stayed at their job, shoveling in the coal. Workers were
also serving free drinks at the bar. Survivors also reported that some
groups were singing hymns so loudly that they could understand the words
from the life boats. What would YOU do with your last moments to live?)
E. As the water rises
around you, think about your life. If you could go back and change one
thing about your life, what would it be? (i.e., what kinds of regrets
would you have--and you can’t say “I wouldn’t have bought a ticket on this
ship”!)
Group 3.
You are alive today, and you know what happened to the Titanic.
LEADER: Ask the following questions and try to get EVERY group member to
answer.
A. What do you think
caused this tragedy? (Historical note: there is no single “right” answer,
but there are several major contributing factors. Try to list as many
factors as your group can think of.)
B. If you could
contact the people in England one week before the Titanic sailed, what
would you tell them? (list at least five things, and use English for
making suggestions; for example: You should look out for icebergs all
night. Tell the captain that he ought to…)
C. Everyone thought
the Titanic was unsinkable. If you tell them it is going to sink, do you
think they would believe you? Why or why not? If not, would you try to
convince them anyway?
D. Some of the passengers had nightmares
predicting the disaster. They tried to warn their loved ones, but no one
listened. In your real life (today) have you ever had someone try to
convince you of something you did not believe? What was it? How did it
make you feel, especially if you thought he/she was crazy? Why do people
try so hard to convince others about “unbelievable” things?
(Note: In settings
with international students, the answers to these questions have presented
many opportunities for comments about some of the most important things
about life. Let group three present their answers last, for this seems to
really open doors for a good discussion. Allow people in the other groups
to participate and make comments. To (A), one said “they put too much
trust in something which was not trustworthy”; to (C) they said they would
“have to” tell people, even though they knew many would not listen.
Another student said that, as a Christian, this is how he felt (that is,
he knows that those who don’t know Jesus are heading for certain disaster,
and even though he knows that not everyone will listen to his warning, his
ethics say he “has to” try to warn people.) Encourage students to express
their own opinions in response to these questions.
----------------------------------------
(non-leader card)
Group 1.
You are the lucky ones. You are on a life boat, looking back as the ship
sinks. All of you have a parent, spouse, child, brother or sister on the
ship.
A. Your boat is not full. Should you turn
back and look for survivors?
B. In your real life (today), what are some
of the risks involved in helping others?
C. When you see the ship disappear, how do
you feel? What do you think you will remember the most (for the rest of
your life)?
D. If you could send a message to a loved
one on the ship before it goes down, what would it be?
(non-leader card)
Group 2.
You are not as lucky as group 1. You are standing on the ship after the
last lifeboat has pulled away.
A. How do you feel?
B. You have no way to get off, but there is
always the possibility that a rescue ship will come quickly, or that the
ship will not really sink. How long do you believe that this ship is
unsinkable? What will it take to make you change your mind?
C. If your real life (today), what does it
take to make you admit that you need help from others?
D. Once you are convinced that the ship
WILL sink, what will you do until the last moment (you may have between 15
minutes to an hour left to live)?
E. As the water rises around you, think
about your life. If you could go back and change one thing about your
life, what would it be? (i.e., what kinds of regrets would you have--and
you can’t say “I wouldn’t have bought a ticket on this ship”!)
(non-leader card)
Group 3.
You are alive today, and you know what happened to the Titanic.
A. What do you think caused this tragedy?
(Historical note: there is no single “right” answer, but there are several
major contributing factors. Try to list as many factors as your group can
think of.)
B. If you could contact the people in
England one week before the Titanic sailed, what would you tell them?
(list at least five things, and use English for making suggestions; for
example: You should look out for icebergs all night. Tell the captain that
he ought to…)
C. Everyone thought the Titanic was
unsinkable. If you tell them it is going to sink, do you think they would
believe you? Why or why not? If not, would you try to convince them
anyway?
D. Some of the passengers had nightmares
predicting the disaster. They tried to warn their loved ones, but no one
listened. In your real life (today) have you ever had someone try to
convince you of something you did not believe? What was it? How did it
make you feel, especially if you thought he/she was crazy? Why do people
try so hard to convince others about “unbelievable” things?
|
Your favorite search engine (google/baidu/etc) will lead
you to lots more information about the Titanic, but here is a link to the
Titanic Historical Society:
http://www.titanic1.org/
Here is a link to a cartoon-like booklet about the Titanic
(in Chinese); I think it is very interesting.
http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0373/0373_01.asp
Role Play help: I like to
assign students actual people on the Titanic, and tell them to mingle as
if they were that person (perhaps on the first day of the cruise, waiting
for a "useless" lifeboat drill). I play the part of designer Thomas
Andrews. To get info about real people, visit
www.encyclopedia-titanica.org/titanic-passenger-list/ (click on any
name to learn about them). BETTER YET: assign students to choose someone
before class (as homework)!
A really interesting "extra exercise" (for older students)
can be found here:
http://www.andersonkill.com/titanic/facts.htm This is Anderson Kill &
Olick's Titanic mock trial site (designed for classroom use). They
designed it for Take Your Daughter to Work Day, and it was so popular that
they put it on line. In this mock trial, they staged the trial of The
White Star Line, the operator of the R.M.S. Titanic. The site has
information about sinking victim Hans Jensen, his fiancé Carla Christine
Jensen who sues on Hans' behalf, the defendant White Star Lines and the
witnesses, the Titanic's Second Officer Lightoller and Swedish military
attaché Bjornstrom-Steffansson. A memoranda of law explaining negligence
law and White Star's defenses to negligence are on the website along with
an exhibit showing where each party was as the ship was being evacuated. A
set of links provides more information about Titanic, the U.S. judicial
process and Law Day.
This
figure was given to me during a visit to Molly’s house in Denver
(2004). Her all-electric house cost $35,000 at the time—and there were
not many electric homes in Denver at the beginning of the 20th
century.
|
See our
Website Standards and Use Policy
regarding the sources of definitions
used on this website.
This resource was created for our students under our
understanding of "fair use" for educational resources.
This page does not imply any consent from or relationship
with the publisher(s) or producer(s).
© 2014 Michael Krigline, all
rights reserved. As far as I am concerned, people are allowed to print/copy
it for personal or classroom use.
(see Website Standards and Use Policy)
Back to EFL Movie Study Guides
index page
|
Click in the boxes below to go to some of our most popular pages. If
you get lost, just click "Home."
See our
Policy
regarding the use of materials available at Krigline.com or
Krigline.com.cn |